Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

Nope, YouTube blocks some videos from being played and I'm not getting around those in any way. Some videos have ads in them that come up from the bottom, those are preserved and not touched.


sort by: page size:

I do, but YouTube constantly finds a way around it. I've been running Adblock Plus and Ghostery Lite, but YouTube ads have poked their way through again.

Some videos have ads as part of the video. Can't do anything about those, sorry.

I'm talking about the videos that have YouTube ads embedded within them that interrupt the video while it's playing.

That trick also appears to work for some pay-for-view websites (as do 'archive' and '12ft ladder' work for some websites). Again, I don't have enough items to prove it and I can't remember which website it was that I tried it on when it worked.

I boycott websites that demand money. "Plenty more fish in the sea."


Sadly, not anymore - used to be the case quite a while ago, but not today anymore as the ads come from the same domains the videos are streamed from.

Those simpler popover-ads which can be closed clicking an X in the upper right corner still are blocked tho...

Spilling my secret tho (and YouTube execs hate me for it!): i block YouTube in my mind and only rarely go to it if i really need to watch a video (which, for me, is rarer than i ever thought it'd be).


Its possible to not retrieve ads, at least for some videos. I never see ads on the ones I watch. I do not use an ad blocker, I just exercise control over HTTP and DNS. Could you provide an example of a video where you believe its impossible not to retrieve ads.

I think I've had issues before where YouTube refused to play videos at all while I had my AdBlocker blocking the ads. Not sure whether it was intentional.

Some video ads (on YouTube and elsewhere) can detect AdBlock and refuse to play the video.

I think AdBlock may help. BTW those ads are added by YouTube (not me)

YouTube seems to be in this amazing degraded state for me where videos play just fine, but it isn't showing me ads.

Apparently not, since you're still seeing ads on Youtube. Which adblocker are you even using that doesn't block those?

Not with the YouTube app, but with the browser, you somewhat can.

I used adguard and it works for like 80 to 90% of the time. For the time where ad did show up, I just reload the page and it is gone.


No they come from the same domain as the video that you are trying to watch. If you want to block YouTube ads, then use uBlockOrigin.

Yes and no. I was suspecting something was up with YouTube ads because I'm getting this error "An error occurred. Please try again later. (Playback ID: ...)" with the extension Improve YouTube!.

When I disable it the error disappears. Also when I reload the page while it's on, I can then watch the videos. But that's really annoying. Usually the video page with the error will refresh automatically after a while, so I suspect the error refers to the actual ad and not the main video. And after the YouTube has determined that the ad has played (or thinks I have watched it) for long enough the main video gets loaded automatically which of course does not cause an error since it's not blocked.

Interestingly when I disable the Improve YouTube! extension ads are being blocked normally. I use uBlock Origin and Gostery as well.


I think he means the ad thumbnails, not the in-video ads themselves. Ublock hasn't been able to hide them for a while now.

Actually, no. > they are served from the same inscrutable urls as real video

This may be right, so host based adblocking may not work.

However, uBlock origin etc definitely block youtube ads and it works as a browser extension so they have access to the DOM and probably do something there.


uBlock can also do this. I suppose if the ads cannot be retrieved, the video is supposed to handle it smoothly.

The only ads that cannot be blocked are those that streams over the same origin server, like Twitch's new embedded ads.


As far as I can tell YouTube has made an effort to detect uBlock, and show full ads.

This isn't about the ads that are inserted by YouTube. This is trying to block parts of the main video that are ads.

No, I meant the ads injected by Youtube before the video that cannot be skipped. Those are completely removed by uBlock origin.

I'm not too bothered by sponsored segments in the videos themselves. If they annoy me a couple of right arrow presses are enough to skip them.


uBlock to the rescue. I didn't see any ads. Although it doesn't always work on stupid auto-play videos.
next

Legal | privacy