Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

I mean, that would reduce congestion too:)


sort by: page size:

It would also solve congestion, though.

It would also benefit everyone else because there would be less congestion.

It would also reduce traffic in cities.

Absolutely, I just don't don't know how much that will increase congestion. I don't think it would actually be a 2x worse experience due.

what’s the solution to congestion?

I imagine it could also make congestion more efficient. I believe a big factor to congestion is human behavior. We at least have good ideas about better ways to drive during congestion.. which humans rarely follow.

Traffic would be a lot better in congested parts of the US as well.

How would they "reduce or eliminate congestion"? Congestion is inherently caused by too many people trying to go to or through the same place at the same time. That's not possible without reducing the amount of people trying to travel during a given time period in a given place.

> "such a scheme would greatly reduce congestion"

It might reduce congestion on roads, but would greatly increase congestion on trains. And many are full already!


To get less congestion you would need fewer journeys, as this technology is likely to make travel cheaper I think we can expect the opposite.

The main point is to get congestion out of roads and your solution is to increase congestion. Nice!

The research on that is pretty clear that it does alleviate congestion, the question is for how long. It can definitely take a while before that extra capacity is used up.

That is easily solved by congestion charging.

I think it could help solve congestion as a problem too. Maybe cars could book their routes, and the road brokers will maximise for #cars/destination instead of allowing people to keep piling in even after the useful capacity is exceeded.

This would not reduce traffic, though. In fact it would increase traffic, because now cars are transiting between revenue trips instead of waiting at the curb.

Also mitigates road congestion

> just opening the lane would decrease congestion for everyone

Adding lanes adds demand, and you get just as much (usually more!) congestion as before.


Removing congestion is best done by trying to make people live closer to where they work.

Seems like they should lower the congestion toll there. Easy problem to observe and solve.
next

Legal | privacy