Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

90% self-edit, 10% friend with English degree. In hindsight, an editor is absolutely worth it having worked with them on commercial projects.


sort by: page size:

Friends of friends mainly. English majors are never very far from professional circles, and several have found that contract tech editing is a way to pay bills while working on items closer to their core.

Agreed, having good editors is highly valuable.

This is accurate. I would add that, in my experience, the value-add of working with a technical editor to shape the book and stay on track is definitely worth the cost of an editor.

And then there are typesetters, copywriters, graphists, reviewers, marketers and distribution platforms that do a lot of the work of making a book successful. Sure, writing is critical, but bringing a high quality book to readers requires a lot of work that you have to do yourself when self-publishing.


Freelance editors are pretty cheap. I don't know about their quality, however.

I've been on both the tech editing and author sides. It really depends on the quality of people that you get working with you.

Hell, I wish some of these publishers had editing friends.

Ample pay to hang out with your friends, and skilled editors?

I just wish some of these self-publishing authors had editing friends.

Trusted human editors.

You only need an editor if you're trying to sell your work.

Are you hiring editors? It feels like they might be inexpensive in this market.

However, having an editor that will engage with your work and provide expert feedback will make your work better, as well as save overall time.

It's not quality versus quantity - it's paying for expert assistance. This isn't cheating, mind you - it's something every one of us will do, given the option. However, wealthy institutions can pay for it, and other institutions cannot - that leaves the academic to either pay out of their own pocket (say, if they have a partner who is in our industry and can afford to), or go without.


What about freelance editors?

How did you come across these high-quality editors? Just curious.

Learning a good editor is an investment. You sacrifice some productivity and time now for a massive return on your investment later. Stating the obvious, I know, but so is this article.

A professional editor can have a substantial impact on the clarity and impact of what you write. Good professional editors are rare and fairly costly. I work regularly with a a writer/editor who has been a great help. Contact me off list (drallison@gmail.com) and I will be happy to provide a referral.

How did you find an editor? Do you pay them or do they work pro bono?

It's also important to note that editing is not just making sure your copy is grammatically correct -- that's called copyediting, and you can pay for that by the page. It's pretty easy to find a copyeditor.

A good editor is someone who knows good writing and will tell you if you're producing crap. They should also be able to tell you if you're writing to the current zeitgeist.

There's value to having good editorial support but, IMHO, it's not worth signing over all your rights and earning potential.

You can outsource all phases of editorial and production, the big houses already do.


According to undisclosed sources, a user gives around $1 per year to an editor of this kind, so yes, it's a massive difference!
next

Legal | privacy