Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

> fascist propaganda

Huge opportunity here to censor your disfavored groups by calling them fascist, which has, in recent times, evolved from being a political science term, to being a very broad type of insult/accusation usable against almost anyone you don’t like.



sort by: page size:

> particularly given fascism is hard to define

Than don't throw around "fascist" as an insult, which seems to be incredibly common.


> I suspect that “fascism” is increasingly a popular slur even for Americans who aren’t so terminally online, and because a word’s meaning is popularly determined by its usage, that means that it’s pointless to complain that they are “using it wrong”.

If you're right that it's becoming such, than I would agree it's simply changing its meaning, I'm not a presciptivist.

However, from my experience, which is limited to online content, I've only seen accusations of fascism being used by left-wing speakers against right-wing (or perceived right-wing) adversaries.

So, my theory is that the term actually retains most of its original meaning even by those throwing it around willy-nilly. It is then not a wrong use of the term nor a novel use, but in fact a sign of increasingly extreme language. That is, people who call you fascist for not caring whether you add alt text to an image aren't using fascist to mean generic bad person, they actually intend to compare your actions to Hitler.

It's similar to how "socialist" is used by right-wing pundits. When they call a boss who raises employee wages "socialist", they are not using that as a generic insult, they explicitly mean to compare that boss with Stalin or Chavez or other such boogeymen.

I think it's all a sign of increasingly more extreme discourse. I would actually be much happier to find out that you are in fact right and fascist is just a more generic insult now.


> By recognizing euphemisms/dog whistles, and rhetoric used by fascists.

Wait, your serious definition of "fascism" is "things said by fascists"???

This is circular. Try a definition that doesn't reference itself.

> news figures such as Tucker Carlson use white nationalist talking points

So being a fascist means quoting people who are protecgted by the First Amendment?

> The president calling human subhuman

So being a fascist means being an insulting jerk?

Sounds like you fit the present mold perfectly - you find something that offends you, slap "fascist" on it, and move on.

(and for bonus points you apparently brigade and downvote opposing views)


>Sounds pretty fascist to me.

Dude, "fascist" does not mean "something I think is bad."


> fascist

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.


>> N-words and F-words freely.

What are the F words? Fascist?


> Unfortunately usually the opposite happens and instead the recipient will wall themselves off from the provider of the message.

Probably because it often feels like that's the intent of people name-calling others "fascists."

The best quote about fascism is and remains: "In Italy, fascists divide themselves into two categories: fascists and antifascists."


They're fascists. But it apparently hurts peoples feelings to say that outloud.

I've seen it used against people spouting QAnon, Big Pharma mind control vaccine theories and support for fascist elements of various governments like USA, China, Turkey, Russia, and Poland. Seems appropriate to me. It's not healthy to tolerate these folks, especially the fascists.

> Just as a reminder there are two types of fascists: fascists and anti-facists

First of all this is the kind of shit fascists typically say. Secondly how does that even follow?!


> the term antifascist certainly didn't age well

antifa?

the political left has never stopped using the term fascist as a pejorative, it's thrown around quite liberally even today


> fascism. Such a populist movement

What is fascism? Look at the bottom of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definitions_of_fascism wrt Orwell's comments, and "Fascist as insult".


The term "fascist" now means "anyone who disagrees with me."

> I'm sorry, but you don't get to do that! `fascism` already has an established meaning. Please make up a new word for what you believe `fascism` means

I see your point, but honestly, that's not how language work. Changes in meaning over time are not so uncommon, and "fascist" has been used in a loose sense for years (at least in Italian), but looking at Wikipedia this holds for English too.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Definitions_of_fascism


> clearly a fascist state

I think everyone is very confused with what “fascist” means. Some say not having a gender-neural bathroom is “fascist”. But anyway, it seems you’re very set on not liking someone, so it’s better to leave you alone.


>when the president in power has insinuated the assassination of his opponents, encouraged his supporters to engage in violence, been spinning outlandish lies about the former president wiretapping him, etc, well I call that fascism ¯\_(?)_/¯

Consider looking up the definition, because the definition of fascism is not "having a leader who makes dumb statements".

Nor is this word a label for "a politician who makes you feel really bad emotions".

It means a certain type of government policy.


> Do you use fascist techniques like criminalizing speech to stop the spread of fascist ideas? Or do you simply hope fascist ideas don't take hold?

If you resort to fascist techniques, then fascist ideas clearly have taken hold.


"fascist" means "people I think are organized bullies"

> Do you use fascist techniques like criminalizing speech

“Criminalizing speech” by itself isn't a particularly fascist technique, since it's been done by movements all over the political spectrum, starting long before fascism. Fascism (in the broad sense) isn't really defined much by technique (you could perhaps credit Naziism or Italian Fascism specifically with some techniques, like the distinct propaganda approach of the Nazis, but even that isn't as distinguishing as the ideological goals of the movement.)

next

Legal | privacy