Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

You're putting words into his mouth. Particularly the first one is not at all what he wrote.


sort by: page size:

I'm taking issue with his first sentence, not second.

That's not from the first paragraph, and, at least to me, doesn't explain what he was getting at with it.

That is correct. His words, not mine.

I think you're seeing something you want to see rather than actually seeing what he wrote. None of that has anything to do with what he said.

What he says and does are two different things.

How do you know that's not what he meant?

The first half of his sentence is right. The full sentence and implications are not right.

It seems that the title gives a different meaning to the words he actually said.

It's not what #2 says, it's just why he was saying it.

That is not what he said, and again the misuse of quotations to make it seem like that's literally what he said is definitely not helping the situation.

Obviously I'm aware that he didn't write it, and that it doesn't necessarily reflect his personal views. I was being lazy, but it's also true that when most people read those words they picture them coming out of his mouth.

I agree that's what he probably intended, but that's definitely not what he said.

There is another sentence after the one you quote which takes the edge off it. Dropping that part could be construed as willfully taking his words out of context to makes them sound worse. IMHO taken as a whole I think it says more about his lack of understanding than him endorsing anything. But as you say, that's not blatant lying.

What is he specifically saying that is false?

You don't seem to be distinguishing between the things he might be saying as part of his true views and the things he might be saying to achieve some type of goal, so I don't think your interpretation of his behaviour is accurate.

You must have read a different memo. The one he wrote can be described by the second part of your comment.

I see you're taking his first sentence to heart then.

I'm not sure what you mean. He literally said that to me in a face to face conversation.

He's quoting the text I mentioned.
next

Legal | privacy