Hacker Read top | best | new | newcomments | leaders | about | bookmarklet login

People value trustworthiness, and Musk's track record with public statements about his businesses definitely isn't the best in that regard -- though that largely concerns the utopian predictions/promises he likes to make, I suppose. Maybe statements of his about the current state of affairs are more reliable.


sort by: page size:

Musk is known to make predictions which fail and to make announcements which are either false or misleading.

Musk does a lot - but says even more, and some of what he says robs him of trust.


I don't really trust Musk on his word.

According to Musk. Are people still trusting the things he says?

I’m not a huge Musk fan, but his shortcoming seems to be more having unreasonable projections about the future. I’m not aware of him lying about things in the present.

I'm not sure why would anyone would trust what Musk says without independent confirmation...

I think the point is that Musk has proven that he can't be fully trusted.

I think that this person is more trustworthy than Musk. After reading Musk's depositions he is not a person that I would consider to be honest and forthright.

Musk has lied repeatedly in public, so it's difficult to assume good faith from him.

Musk has said a lot of things that didn't ring true.

I'm just generally skeptical of Musk. He is great at putting out blog posts that people don't treat like the press releases they are.

I've been arguing about this article on another forum, and have been looking closely at how Musk is interpreting his own data - and he's being loose and fancy-free with it (both sides have engaged in embellishment, it seems). As a result, I don't think he's a shining bastion of honesty - I wouldn't trust Tesla any more than any other entity.

I believe you can summarize Mr. Musk's persona (including his speech and promises made or hinted at) as "unreliable".

How reliable is Musk to report on this?

Musk says lots of nonsense. I wouldn't believe him just because he says something.

I mean, it wouldn't surprise me if that's true, but it's pretty risky just taking Musk's word for it.


How reliable is Musk to report on anything?

> Musk is brutally honest - with the people he works with, with the investors, with his followers on twitter and everyone. He is brutally honest by letting them know on their face what he thinks is right and wrong.

He is brutally honest when it benefits him. But he is completely willing to lie when it suits him. See:

https://elonsbrokenpromises.com/

Or search for "Musk broken promise" or "Musk failed prediction" to see many other examples. You might argue that, "Well, he honestly intended these things to pass." But at his level of power, I believe there is a moral obligation to be reliable in one's public predictions.


Anything Musk says is unreliable with a fairly substantial history as proof.

I wouldn't take him at his word. Musk says a lot of shit in his tweets.

It works both ways. Musk frequently exaggerates, makes ridiculous claims, and offers fact-free promises. I don't take him at his word either.
next

Legal | privacy